Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is a complete non-sequitur. Nobody is actually burning books. Or even talking about burning books.

Also, burning books is perfectly legal and ethical — not all books are valuable or worth keeping around, and not all acts book-burning are acts of repression. That's what the Nazi book burnings and Fahrenheit 451 were: acts of repression.

It's a bit like saying iWork gives you a bad vibe because Nazis made people work in death camps.



Presumably the Kindle and Matchbook names are designed to evoke book burning, unless there is an alternative interpretation I have missed. Matchbook = taking a match to a book, i.e. burning it, just as you should use your now-obsolete paper books as kindling. To me, book burning has terrible connotations, even though no actual book burning is being done (although it does seem encouraged by the naming). Perhaps I am alone in this regard.


For what it's worth, the official explanation from its namer is this [1]:

    "Jeff [Bezos, the CEO] wanted to talk about
    the future of reading, but in a small, not
    braggadocio way. We didn't want it to be
    'techie' or trite, and we wanted it to be
    memorable, and meaningful in many ways of
    expression, from 'I love curling up with
    my Kindle to read a new book' to 'When I'm
    stuck in the airport or on line, I can 
    Kindle my newspaper, favorite blogs or 
    half a dozen books I'm reading.'" ...
    Kindle means to set alight or start to
    burn, to arouse or be aroused, to make or
    become bright. The word’s roots are from
    the Old Norse word kyndill, meaning
    Candle. “I verified that it had deep roots
    in literature,” adds Hibma. “From
    Voltaire: ‘The instruction we find in
    books is like fire. We fetch it from our
    neighbours, kindle it at home, communicate
    it to others and it becomes the property
    of all.’”
[1] http://www.printmag.com/article/who-named-the-kindle-and-why...


No, I don't really see that. When I hear Kindle, I think more of nurturing, or beginning a fire. A fire needs to begin somewhere, just as an idea must. And must also be nurtured, and built upon, something that books do. That's what I see when I see "Kindle". Matchbook just goes along with the fire theme of Kindle, as publicfig said.


I agree. Specifically, the names remind me of a quotation by Victor Hugo - "To learn to read is to light a fire; every syllable that is spelled out is a spark".


> not all books are valuable or worth keeping around

Exhibits A & B: http://i.imgur.com/So8rgje.jpg


Obligatory xkcd: http://xkcd.com/750/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: