Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

[flagged]


> Yet we've wiped out quite a bit of their military infrastructure and have complete control over the skies.

How can you believe that the US has "complete control over the skies" given today's events?


Oh yeah, its going great, so much achieved for only 30B and untold human lives, the winning!


Well we’re talking about Iran instead of the President’s “dealings” with a bevy of children so mission accomplished!


We must be using different definitions for ‘complete’. I think Iran is using loitering anti-air missiles with IR seeking which seems to be effective. Maybe this sudden spike is reflective of receiving new equipment from China.


[flagged]


> I guess my definition is “US can do whatever it wants without contest” and that seems to be the case here.

Whatever it wants, as long as that doesn't include flying aircraft or going through the strait.


Maybe ericmay is arguing that the US wants its planes shot down?


I would term it; the US has air dominance but the airspace is still contested as evident by the recent losses.

Also, I think the US is still predominantly using standoff munitions instead of switching to dumb munitions because the airspace is still contested.


[flagged]


> Yes the US probably is still using precision weapons because, well, unlike the Iranian government we don't want to use so-called dumb munitions and indiscriminately bomb civilians or civilian targets.

Are you referring to the "precision" weapons that hit the girls' school?


The us has air dominance but not air supremacy, which is why missiles are mostly used rather than bombs with gps kits, requiring to get much closer.

And the US has been very keen to bomb civilians and civilian infrastructure, along with Israelis, since the start of the war [0]. The US-Israelis are guilty of war crimes.

The recent bombing of an unfinished bridge is another example of the US-Israeli actions, especially since they did a double-tap to kill rescuers. [1]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Qeshm_Island_desalination...

[1] https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/firestorm-for-hegseth-a...


US did murder 170 girls in Minab school, and hit many civilian targets, including a water desalination plant.

Yes US is using precision weapons, but not because they want to avoid indiscriminate bombing.

It's because US wants to precisely bomb specific civilian targets


One could argue that the IRGC, much like Hamas, purposely builds military headquarters and other facilities near hospitals, schools, and civilian infrastructure precisely to use civilians as human shields.


Even if that's true, it doesn't justify killing a bunch of girls. I honestly can't understand how anyone gets to this point.


nobody can argue that, unless you are a war criminal trying to justify your war crimes


There's a day care center across I-95 from the Pentagon.


> have complete control over the skies.

If we had complete control over the skies, we wouldn't be losing aircraft, would we?


Not sure why you're getting downvoted. It is completely expected to lose aircraft in an operation of this scale, against an opponent with this level of sophistication. People put way too much stock in all of these modern stealth systems and whatnot. Stealth, for example, is a buzzword. It will give a slight edge, but it's not going to make your aircraft completely invisible and unshootable.


Stealth really should be qualified as radar-stealth, not optical stealth and not infrared stealth.

Iran is using infrared seekers to shut down planes and US pilots never get a warning of incoming missile due to Iran's passive IR seekers


The Iran war is going exactly to plan and this isn’t a bad day for the US administration?




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: