Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Of course not. Just as no system is truly secure. But let's not dive off into hypotheticals, let's talk practically. With cookies off you are practically untrackable.

I just tried your link. Here are my results: "Your browser fingerprint appears to be unique among the 2,399,190 tested so far."

I'm one in roughly 2.4 million. That's untraceable enough for me :p



One in 2.4 million means you are unambiguously uniquely identified out of 2.4 million clients, which is the exact opposite of untraceable. If your browser fingerprint was similar to 2.4 million other browser fingerprints, then you would be untraceable.

1 in 2.4m is being similar to ~150 other Americans. Not good odds for hiding among the crowd once non-client browser specific identifying clues are taken into account, such as browsing habits. 1 in 2.4m is being similar to ~400 other facebook users, and facebook knows a lot more about its users than just the client browser fingerprint.


Within the group of people using Panopticlick, you're just as trackable without cookies as with cookies -- that doesn't seem very untrackable to me. Note that it's one in 2.4M at the moment, but that's the best it's going to get because the number of people trying Panopticlick is only going to go up.


> Your browser fingerprint appears to be unique among the 2,399,190 tested so far

That isn't 1:2.4e6, that is at best 1:2.4e6, they have only run 2.4 million tests and so can't say anything more than that. Your browser fingerprint could easily could be unique in the whole world.


@andrewaylett:

Until I change just one of those identifiable metrics, that is, right? As soon as I change, for instance, my screen resolution I am another unique user and am no longer identified with the previously unique fingerprint.

Surely, if someone installed insidious software on every single page of the internet and tracked me everywhere, there could be a way to use some fuzzy logic to re-identify myself. But we're way into the deep end on hypothetical again, right?

My main point is that, practically speaking, it isn't very.


Not really. If you change those metrics and then re-login to any account that is cooperating with the person trying to track you, you've lost your anonymity again.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: