Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That doesn't really answer the question. Perhaps I should rephrase:

You were replying to someone who stated this, I believe:

> Maybe a bit better, but you're still overgeneralizing in order to demonize an entire group of people.

To which you responded:

> Cops aren't a marginalized group.

Why does being a marginalized group matter in this context? Why does not being a "marginalized group" mean it's okay to overgeneralize and/or demonize? What is a "marginalized group" in this context? Why is one not allowed to overgeneralize and demonize a marginal group, but one is allowed to for groups that do not hold this status?

The more meta question is: Why is overgeneralizing in order to demonize a group of people acceptable in any circumstance? I don't think it is, because once you start carving out exceptions, all you end up doing is just justifying and reinforcing your own biases.



>>>> "Black people are abusive, violent thugs, within a subculture of violent thuggery, in cities which lack..."

>>>> Maybe a bit better, but you're still overgeneralizing in order to demonize an entire group of people.

>>> cops aren't a marginalized group

>> why does this matter

> There's a difference between punching down on marginalized groups, compared to speaking against / badly about authority figures.

hope this clears it up.


Nope, doesn't clear anything up. Redeclaring your statement doesn't really answer any questions that arose from your original statement.

I still have these questions: What is a marginalized group, and why is that important? Why does being an "authority figure" mean it's okay to overgeneralize?

You're declaring these to be important factors in whether or not it's "okay" to overgeneralize specifically for the purposes of demonizing an entire population. I'm arguing that generalizing like this is never acceptable. In fact, I'm arguing that doing this is actively harmful to the goal you ostensibly are serving by demonizing this group in particular (unless you have ulterior motives, I suppose).

You have yet to explain why it's acceptable, and what makes it acceptable. Further, you should explain why overgeneralizing like this is useful, and how it actually furthers your goal.

Actually, I'm not sure what your goal is, other than to spread hate?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: