Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm not sure I agree.

I mean, a silicon valley developer getting paid $200k/year might fix a bug in some open source software for free because it was bothering him and he wanted to give something back to the project.

But if I offer that same developer $100 to bail on date night with his wife to fix a bug for me? That's not an offer I'd expect him to take me up on.



I broadly agree with your point - that in many situations people feel happier and more willing to donate their time than to be paid but paid less than they feel their time is worth commercially.

But you made the point badly, confusing things by adding in the date night - so that instead of comparing "fix bug for free" vs "fix bug and be paid, but much less than their usual hourly rate", you instead compared "fix bug for free at a time that suits them" vs "fix bug at an inconvenient time and get paid less than their usual hourly rate".

I can't actually work out why you bothered to bring bailing on a date night into it at all...


I mention that merely to illustrate that our hypothetical $200k developer has good things he could be doing with his limited discretionary time.

The time spent fixing a bug for $100 doesn't get magicked out of nowhere - that's time that could be spent meeting friends, doing sports, spending time with family, reading books, creating art, enjoying good food and wine, learning new things, or even sleeping!

For a similar concept expressed in a wordier way, read about Maslow's hierarchy of needs [1]. Our hypothetical developer's physiological and safety needs are fully met - and their unmet needs won't be much helped by $100. I avoided this and chose the wording I did because some of Maslow's wording like "self-actualization" and "transcendence" kinda invites confusion IMHO.

Far less confusing and questionable, I thought, to merely argue that sex is more fun than software development. But apparently not...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: