Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The spite wars continue

There are consequences to regulations/legislation. You can't have it both ways. News at 11...

The privacy concerns are real, and EU regulations have teeth. No matter how iron-clad Apple's agreement is with OpenAI, it's still a significant liability since data protection and the rest that comes with this tech is outside of Apple's control. So now EU citizens don't get to play with this new feature. It's pretty simple.



> and EU regulations have teeth

As someone who has been involved in this journey from the beginning, essentially starting from a point akin to "fuck the EU, they're laughably ignorable" it's really interesting to read this sentence. We can work with that.


> essentially starting from a point akin to "fuck the EU, they're laughably ignorable" it's really interesting to read this sentence

If you don't have a physical presence within the EU, you can and probably should ignore their laws/regulations. There's very little if anything they can do to you. This includes GDPR and other "viral" laws. EU citizens seem to believe their laws apply around the world - they do not.

If you have a physical presence within the EU, like Apple does, then you cannot afford to be flippant with EU laws and regulations. They have real teeth, as you would expect for any country you have a physical presence in. Just as Apple cannot ignore US law since they are based here, they cannot ignore EU law since they are also based there.

EU regulations have consequences - both good and bad. If Apple cannot guarantee compliance with EU regulations/laws, then they will have to remove or limit features that might get them into trouble.

If EU citizens want this feature, then the regulations would need to change. It cannot be more simple than this.

A lot of people enjoy eating the cake these days...


> both good and bad

Not arguing against that. The first thing is to be able to steer. And then you can steer in the right direction. So I'm glad it seems we'll finally be able to steer. Now we can figure out where exactly we want to end up.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: