Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I'm a short fiction writer. Do you think I could get one of these new models to write a good story?

I'd want to train it to include foreshadowing, suspense, relatable characters and perhaps a twist ending that cleverely references the beginning.



I’ve thought about this and tested it a lot, it doesn’t work.

The reason is, the models don’t understand content or even context, they just recognize patterns and can generate similar patterns which we then interpret.

Case in point, a photo of an Astronaut on a horse is not actually an astronaut on a horse, it’s a 2D pixel map of light that our eyes then interpret to mean an astronaut on a horse. It’s even easier to understand this listening to the generated singing. It sounds just like singing - but it’s not language at all and doesn’t mean anything, it’s just a very similar pattern.

These AI models are great at making things that look like a pattern that to us means something, but they don’t generate semantically meaningful content itself.

So when you do this with GPT3 or other models and long-form narrative it falls apart pretty fast as the model can’t keep straight things like characters and their internal personalities and motives, nor the overall plot arc.

But! You can definitely feed in prompts and ask questions to get ideas and boilerplate - descriptions of people and places come out especially well - and then you can edit that and use it to accelerate your writing process.


they can only do about 150 words at a time, so you'd struggle to get anything longform out of it. You can keep asking it over and over but then its liable to forget previous information. You'd do better with a prompt that repeatedly reminds the AI the style its going for and some basic information about the characters, but it's story would likely be quite cliche in many ways. It's something i've experimented with trying to get it to make DND adventure books


I think it is possible. Have you tried interacting with chatGPT on short story?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: