Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> People downvote and don't even understand why.

I think probably initially because it just seemed kind of irrelevant; if this was the 1950s “there’s sex in this sci-fi!” would be notable, but it’s really very standard now, and Jemesin’s depictions aren’t notably graphic, violent, or just plain comically stupid (a common problem). You could put “warning, there’s sex in this” into most discussions of sci-fi novels.

For why THIS comment is downvoted, well, you guessed yourself; obviously it’s the systemic bias against the straights!



> obviously it’s the systemic bias against the straights!

I find it dangerous for my health that you find it funny and normal.

Moreover, even my comments where I say that I'm glad I've helped someone, was downvoted. If that's not bias, I don't know what it is.


To be clear, I was joking. There is obviously no systemic bias against straight people. Don’t be silly.


It's good to know that in this thread at least one person is having fun.

By the way, as for irrelevance; someone has disliked the book for being too "melodramatic", and it had no replies. But when someone dislikes the book because it has graphic gay sex scenes, the whole HN hive-mind unleashes its fury. How's that for irrelevance?

I think that you're a part of the group I was talking about, that they don't even understand why they're downvoting.


So you initially claimed that the same sex relationship warning was neutral but now say you disliked the book because of it. Which is it?

Also, disliking a book that covers LGBT issues is fine, you dont have to like any book. But, disliking a book because it covers LGBT issues is indicative of a certain level of bigotry.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: